Posts Tagged ‘Brooklyn’

Grand Street Bridge

Crosses: Newtown Creek
Connects: Grand Street, Williamsburg and Grand Avenue, Maspeth [satellite map]
Carries: 2 vehicular lanes, 2 pedestrian sidewalks
Design: swing bridge
Date opened: February 5, 1903

The Grand Street Bridge is a through truss swing bridge across Newtown Creek, connecting Maspeth, Queens with Williamsburg, Brooklyn.

Earlier Bridges

In the 1850s Newtown Creek was an incredibly busy and polluted waterway, crowded with ships serving industrial sites like the glue factories, smelting plants, and refineries that lined its shores.

The first bridge to carry Grand Street over Newtown Creek was authorized to be built in 1869, with the cost of construction to be split between the town of Newtown (now a part of present day Queens) and the city of Brooklyn. A contract was awarded in 1874 to the King Iron Bridge & Manufacturing Company of Cleveland, Ohio, and an iron swing bridge was completed at the site the following year. In 1878, the Kings County Board of Supervisors reported that the bridge was already in bad shape; the swing span had become difficult to turn, causing traffic delays to become a commonplace occurrence. By 1881 the bridge had sunk so far into the mud that at high tide the turntable would become partially submerged in the creek. The Joint Committee on Bridges called for its replacement in 1888. A new iron swing bridge with masonry piers opened the following year. Jurisdiction over the bridge was given to the Department of Bridges in 1898 following the consolidation of the five boroughs into the City of New York. In 1899, the US War Department, looking to dredge and widen Newtown Creek, found the bridge to be an obstruction to navigation and ordered yet another bridge to be built on the site.

Current Bridge

On June 11, 1900, Department of Bridges Commissioner John L. Shea advertised for bids on the construction of a new span. On August 7, a contract was awarded to Bernard Rolf for a steel swing bridge at a cost of $173,380. The old bridge was closed on August 27 and a temporary pedestrian bridge made of wood was built. Construction of the new bridge took much longer than initially expected. Labor strikes, poorly made engineering plans, and deliveries of low quality building materials were compounded by problems with the dredging of the creek. The situation improved when prominent bridge engineer Gustav Lindenthal was appointed Bridge Commissioner by Mayor Seth Low in 1902. In November of that year, consulting engineer C.C. Martin was placed in full charge of the project by the Department of Bridges, and construction progressed quickly. The bridge was completed at a cost of $205,672 and opened to traffic on December 12, 1902. The City of New York officially accepted the bridge on February 5, 1903.

Crimes & Accidents

The Grand Street Bridge and the area very close to it on Newtown Creek have been site to numerous crimes and some mysterious drownings. The bridge was left unguarded at night: policemen stationed there left at 8pm and did not return until 4am. In November of 1894 The New York Times detailed a story told to them by George Roeschman, who said he had been approached by three men asking for a match while crossing the bridge one night. When he reached into his pocket, the men grabbed him, put a bag over his head, robbed him of all he had ($10), and tossed him into Newtown Creek. He lived to tell his tale, though his credibility is questionable: the lumber company Roeschman claimed he worked for had no idea who he was. In the same year several other bodies were pulled from the water near the bridge, it being unknown whether they were murdered or drowned. Two men were arrested and sentenced to Sing Sing Prison for taking and burying alive a baby from a Polish woman (of no relation to either) near the bridge.

In January 1896, Polish priest Reverend Leonard Syczek was heard crying out for help from the water by a watchman and two boat captains who happened to be nearby. He was pulled out but died later. It was thought he had fallen in accidentally: the entryways to the bridge were dark at night and it was easy to miss the walkway and fall right into the river. In September of 1927 a Maspeth man drove through the guardrail and off the narrow bridge after colliding with another car. He managed to free himself from his car and was rescued by boat.

Decline

The bridge held up relatively well until the 1950s, when reports of closures became frequent. Between 1952 and 1956 the main shaft on the turntable broke at least three times, each instance requiring a full day’s work for repairs, during which time the bridge was left in the open position to accommodate boat traffic. On June 12, 1975, a proposal was put into place to cut service for bridge openings. Until that time, a tender was employed 24 hours a day on the bridge. The plans were put off for a time, but were eventually put into place. In 2002, the Department of Transportation, who now has jurisdiction over the bridge, proposed turning the bridge into a fixed span, citing the decline of boat traffic that had come to obviate the need for bridge openings. The proposal has yet to be put into place, though bridge openings have become very rare. In 1998 (the most recent year for which data is available), the bridge was opened only 23 times for boat traffic, and another 63 times for testing. Those numbers show a sharp decline from as recent as 1990, when it was opened 610 times for boat traffic, and 42 times for testing.

- – - – - -

References

1885, September 22. The 18th Ward: Its Past and Its Probable Future. Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p. 1.

1894, November 21. Newtown Creek Crimes: George Roeschman’s Story May Throw Light on Them. The New York Times. (ProQuest Document ID: 106880248).

1896, January 26. Drowned in Newtown Creek: Lack of Guards at Grand Street Bridge Responsible for a Life. The New York Times. (ProQuest Document ID: 108219542).

1898, September 18. Channel Narrowed in Newtown Creek. Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p. 5.

1899, January 1. Grand Street Bridge May Be Condemned. Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p. 28.

1900, July 11. The Grand Street Bridge. Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p. 2.

1900, July 23. Grand Street Bridge: Contract for Construction to Go to Bernard Rolf. Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p. 3.

1900, August 27. Work Begun on New Bridge. Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p. 14.

1901, May 8. Grand Street Bridge Delays. Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p. 9.

1903. New York Department of Bridges. The Department of Bridges of the City of New York: A Statement of Facts. New York: The City Club of New York.

1905. New York Department of Bridges. Report of the Commissioner of Bridges to the Hon. George B. McClellan, Mayor of the City of New York, December 31, 1904. New York: Martin B. Brown Co.

1910. Grand Street Swing Bridge. The Engineering Magazine, October 1909 to March 1910.

c1920. New York (City). Historical facts in Connection with New York City Bridges: 1890-1919. New York: City Hall Library.

1927, September 2. Autoist is Unhurt in Drop off Bridge. The New York Times, p. 19. (ProQuest Document ID: 101507495).

1930, May 25. Urges Change in Plan for Newtown Creek. The New York Times, p. 25. (ProQuest Document ID: 97802448).

1952, November 13. Grand Street Bridge Closed. The New York Times, p. 33. (ProQuest Document ID: 84366724).

1956, March 19. Part of Bridge Adrift. The New York Times, p.33. (ProQuest Document ID: 86549396).

1956, May 8. Newtown Creek Span is Stuck. The New York Times, p. 35. (ProQuest Document ID: 86574829).

1975, June 12. Newman, Barry. Ted Kolo Tends the Grand Street Bridge. The Wall Street Journal, p. 20.

2002, February 10. Lippincott, E. E. Sounding a Death Knell for a Long-Forsaken Waterway. The New York Times, p. CY8.

c2010. New York City Department of Transportation. Grand Street Bridge Facts. Retrieved from http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/html/bridges/grandfacts.shtml

Carroll Street Bridge

Crosses: Gowanus Canal
Connects: Carroll Gardens and Park Slope, Brooklyn [satellite map]
Carries: 1 vehicular lane, 2 sidewalks
Design: retractile
Date opened: 1889

The Carroll Street Bridge is a retractile drawbridge that crosses the Gowanus Canal in the borough of Brooklyn. It is notable as the oldest surviving retractile bridge in the United States, with only three others still in existence: two non-operational draws in Boston, and one carrying Borden Avenue over Dutch Kills in the borough of Queens.

Planning and Construction

The bridge was built between 1888-1889 by the New Jersey Steel & Iron Company. It replaced a wooden swing bridge that had become so rotten over the years that city engineers were forced to close it in early 1887 to everything but pedestrian traffic, fearing it would collapse under anything heavier. The Brooklyn Common Council passed a resolution in July 1888 ordering that $1200 be allocated for the repair of the bridge. Brooklyn Mayor Alfred Chapin, following the advice of city engineers who felt that repairs would be useless on such a deteriorated structure, vetoed the resolution and instituted a tax levy that would raise $40,000 to pay for a replacement structure.

Plans for the new bridge were developed soon after. George Ingram and Robert Van Buren, engineers with the Department of City Works preferred a retractile bridge to replace the old swing span, as did local property owners. In September 1888 the old bridge was removed, and a public auction was announced for the sale of the superstructure. Construction of the new one was begun at the end of the year. It opened in September the following year, completed at a cost of $29,600.

Rehabilitation and Landmarking

By the 1980s, the bridge had fallen victim to the city’s deferred maintenance program. The Department of Transportation closed the bridge in 1985 after an inspection revealed multiple holes in the road deck, seriously corroded steel, and a broken operating mechanism. After a $1.5 million overhaul by city workers, the bridge was able to reopen to traffic just in time for the 100th anniversary of its initial opening in 1989.

As a retractile draw, the bridge opens by physically sliding out of the navigation channel on a set of three steel rails, pulled by an electrically operated pulley system. The moving portion of the bridge is a 107-foot long trapezoidal deck, supported in the middle by an iron post-and-truss frame that gives the superstructure the appearance of a suspension bridge. The operating controls for the bridge are located in a polygonal brick house on the west side of the site. The house was built during the bridge’s overhaul project of bricks salvaged from the demolition of the old operating house. One of the more interesting features of the bridge, a sign threatening a five dollar fine for anyone driving over the bridge faster than a walker’s pace, was also added during the overhaul.

The unique style of the this bridge gained it landmark status in 1987, with the Landmarks Preservation Commission citing its “rare and unusual” qualities. This designation is meant to preserve the historical nature of the bridge from being altered without the Commission’s approval.

- – - – - -

References

1888, July 22. A Rotten Bridge. Brooklyn Daily Eagle.

1888, September 10. Notice of Sale of Carroll Street Bridge. Brooklyn Daily Eagle.

1889, September 26. Work on the Carroll Street Bridge completed. Brooklyn Daily Eagle.

1987. Carroll Street Bridge Over the Gowanus Canal, Borough of Brooklyn, built 1888-1889 … [report]. Landmarks Preservation Commission. New York: Landmarks Preservation Commission.

1989, May 21. Gray, Christopher. Getting a Landmark in Shape for its 100th Birthday. The New York Times, p. R12. (ProQuest Document ID: 115633317).

1989, September 24. Pitt, David E. Two Neighborhoods Celebrate Restoration of Their Bridge. The New York Times, p. 40. (ProQuest Document ID: 115642752).

1989, September 29. Bringing Back the Bridges. The New York Times, p. A34. (ProQuest Document ID: 115482009).